How does the loss in the LBRY case affect the crypto industry?
The SEC says LBRY violated securities laws by selling its native tokens
Good afternoon, friends!
The Securities and Exchange Commission won a ruling against LBRY, a blockchain-based file-storage protocol, when a federal judge ruled that the company illegally sold its native LBC tokens in violation of U.S. securities laws.
This ruling could prove to be very problematic for other cryptocurrencies as they could just as easily be labeled securities under the same ruling. If this becomes true and it sets a precedent, it could create a problem going forward for the development of new projects that need to worry about how they produce and offer their utility tokens.
LBRY offers its LBC token to miners who help support its platform, which operates similarly to a decentralized alternative to YouTube, and stores videos that can be watched anywhere and spread everywhere. As it is a decentralized blockchain technology it cannot be censored.
It’s clear that the SEC is continuing to extend its regulatory reach over crypto, but this decision adds extra weight to that mission. And there are a number of industry experts who have already said as much.
On Twitter, Gabriel Shapiro, general counsel at the crypto incubator Delphi Labs, said that LBRY’s “premine” and hold of its own LBC tokens indicated that the decision that the company itself was motivated to improve the value of its own blockchain and not just invest.
“It's dicta, but here the LBRY judge reasons that even if team is completely silent about efforts -- no promises, no contracts -- but premines tokens, that alone creates a sufficient expectation of profits from their efforts in common enterprise to pass the Howey test,” Shapiro said.
The Howey test is used to determine if a tradable asset is a security and thus must be registered with a SEC. Under the test, it is a security if an investor expects a profit from the efforts of others.
“Very bad result,” Shapiro concluded.
Under this result, every blockchain under development could fall under this category, including Ethereum, especially if Ethereum developers happen to hold tokens. A sentiment echoed by Jeremy Kauffman, founder of LBRY.
Without clear, obvious regulatory guidelines, companies working in the crypto space can easily run afoul of these lines that are being drawn out and tumble over them. Certainly, even utility tokens are bought and purchased by some that they will gain value because there are teams working on the underlying projects, and if this turns every utility token into a security this may chill future creators from launching their own.
As usual recent news is below in the bullet points, including some of what’s happened with the FTX meltdown this last and this week — because we just can’t stop watching that happen. Stay tuned for more coming up next week no doubt. In the end, decentralization is a strength.
Thank you for your support!
If you enjoy this newsletter, you'll want to check these links out.
💛 - Send this email to a friend! Even if you’re on the paid version. It’ll get someone else interested, and possibly subscribed!
₿ - I'm the VP at Geosyn Mining, a datacenter for co-locating your bitcoin mining equipment. If you want to learn more about how you can mine bitcoin directly, drop me a line here.
🦢 - Have you started investing in Bitcoin yet? You’ve read about Dollar Cost Averaging, but don’t know where to start? I endorse Swan Bitcoin as a great tool for setting up a disciplined investment regimen, and many of you do, too! If you sign up with this link, I get $10 to help support my efforts with this newsletter.
📧 - Did you get this emailed to you? Click here to try a premium subscription out free for 14-days (generally, two issues).
IRS seizes $3.36 billion in Bitcoin from another Silk Road hacker. The DOJ announced that a Georgia man plead guilty to wire fraud for stealing more than 50,000 from the Silk Road, worth $3.36 billion at the time of seizure, reported Wired.
Blockchain intelligence firm TRM Labs raises $70M in funds. Looking to help companies secure their transactions against illegal and fraudulent activity, TRM Labs raised $70 million in new funding led by Tiger Global, reported Decrypt.
Blockchain Behind the Scenes
The fall of an empire: SBF steps down as CEO and FTX files for bankruptcy. After a brutal week that started with rumors of insolvency and then led to the entire empire crumbling with FTX filing for chapter 11 bankruptcy and founder and CEO Sam Bankman-Fried stepping down.
…And then FTX gets hacked. Mere hours after filing for bankruptcy protection, funds appeared to be draining from the exchange’s accounts as over $600 million in cryptocurrency was drained from its coffers and admins of the Telegram chat say the exchange was hacked.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Ask Doctor Bitcoin to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.